Book of Mark - Chapter 9 - Verse 16
Meaning
When Jesus asked the scribes, "What question ye with them?", he was inquiring about the nature of their discussions. Jesus was aware that the scribes were engaged in a dialogue with his disciples, and he wanted to know the topic of conversation. By asking this question, Jesus demonstrated his interest in the teachings and beliefs being shared among his followers. Additionally, his question served to highlight the importance of thoughtful inquiry and open communication in the pursuit of knowledge and understanding. It also underscored the value of engaging in meaningful conversations that promote learning and spiritual growth. Overall, this verse serves as a reminder to approach discussions with a spirit of curiosity and a willingness to explore new ideas and perspectives.
Theological Overview
When Jesus asked the scribes in Mark 9:16 "What question ye with them?", He was not simply asking them about their conversation with the disciples. This question carries a deeper theological significance. In this context, Jesus had just come down from the Mount of Transfiguration where He displayed His glory to Peter, James, and John. The scribes were likely challenging the disciples about their inability to cast out a demon from a boy. The question Jesus posed to the scribes could be interpreted as Him challenging their knowledge and understanding of the Scriptures, as well as their motives in questioning the disciples. The word "question" can also be translated as "discuss", implying that Jesus was prompting them to reflect on the true purpose and meaning behind their actions. This verse serves as a reminder for us to examine our own intentions and seek a deeper understanding of our faith through studying the Word of God.